The Valley of the Kings is a particular sector of the Theban necropolis. This article links articles 061, 073 and 078 and sets out the geographical and documentary limits of comparing them.
Chronology and attribution
The first royal tombs of the New Kingdom open a sequence of several dynasties. Debates over attribution and chronology are not settled by the appearance of an entrance alone or by a modern numbering. Article 061 sets out the evidence specific to the monuments it covers.
The tomb of Tutankhamun (073) is known for the circumstances of its discovery and for its relatively well-preserved funerary equipment. That does not mean it is representative of all the royal tombs. The tomb of Seti I (078), far more developed, raises other questions about the extent and decoration of the underground spaces.
Architecture and texts
The tombs have plans, axes and decorative programmes that vary. The funerary images should not be presented as a uniform decoration added to an identical architecture. The individual articles associate the representations with their position and with the historical phase to which they belong.
Popular plans call for particular caution. The drawing of the tomb of Tutankhamun has been corrected in article 073; an error in the arrangement of the chambers would change the meaning of the visit. The present plate is therefore not an architectural plan, but a chart for reading the articles.
Limits of the sector
The Egyptian ministry’s press release places tomb C4 of Valley C about 2.4 kilometres west of the Valley of the Kings. The comparison with the royal tombs is historically relevant; including it in this valley as an immediately neighbouring monument would be topographically wrong.
The Valley of the Kings must also be placed among the other sites of the west bank: the Valley of the Queens, the tombs of dignitaries, the mortuary temples and the village of Deir el-Medina. These places are not mere annexes of the royal tombs.
Discovery, access and conservation
The fame of a tomb sometimes depends more on the story of its discovery than on its place in the development of the plans. Tutankhamun provides the most obvious example: the preservation of part of his funerary equipment transformed his modern reception. Seti I makes it possible to study another relationship between the length of the underground route, decoration and royal ambitions. The two articles are comparable by questions, not by size or state of discovery.
Visitor access, lighting and protective fittings also change the experience of the spaces. The records of the missions must guide the plans and the commentary; a tourist photograph does not always make it possible to distinguish the ancient state, deposits, restorations and recent fittings. The overview sets out these problems before each tomb article examines its own evidence.
Sources
Egyptian ministry, Valley of the Kings: https://egymonuments.gov.eg/archaeological-sites/valley-of-the-kings
UNESCO, Ancient Thebes with its Necropolis: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/87
Egyptian Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities, tomb of Seti I (KV17): https://egymonuments.gov.eg/monuments/tomb-of-sety-i-kv17/